Welcome to Online Ordering!

Sugar Cookie Options

At The Handcrafted Cookie Co, we offer a variety of custom sugar cookies that are sure to delight your taste buds. From beautifully decorated treats for special occasions to everyday favourites, we have something for everyone.

  • Personalized sugar cookies for birthdays, weddings, and more
  • Seasonal designs for holidays like Christmas, Halloween, and Valentine's Day
  • Custom shapes and colors to match your theme
  • Available in multiple flavors: our beloved classic vanilla sugar, chocolate, chocolate chip, peppermint, gingerbread (seasonal flavor) and pumpkin spice (seasonal flavor)

Cookie Cake Options

Indulge in our scrumptious chocolate chip cookie cakes that are perfect for any celebration. Made with the same love and care as our cookies, these cakes are sure to be a hit at your next gathering.

  • Custom designs for birthdays, anniversaries, and special events
  • Personalized messages and decorations
  • Available in various sizes to suit your needs

9in cakes serve 8-12 people

13in cakes serve 12-16 people

Valentine's Day Pre-sale!

Celebrate the holiday of love with treats you'll love: decorated sugar cookies and chocolate chip cookie cakes 

  • Galentines Day anyone??? Love You a Latte gift boxes are perfect for the friend or fellow coffee and cookie lover in your life! Complete with two decorated sugar cookies and a $5 Starbucks gift card, these adorable boxes are a great way to say "I love you"...a latte 😉💕

 

  • 9in Heart Shaped Cookie Cakes with pink vanilla buttercream icing...what better treat to share with the ones you love! 🍪

 

  • If you prefer not to share, the mini 6in Round Cookie Cake is just what you need! Complete with either chocolate or vanilla buttercream, the choice is up to you! 🤎🩷❤️

 

  • Mini Conversation Heart Cookies are an adorable gift to give this Valentine's Day. This take on the classic candy of the holiday will have you feeling festive! Each box comes with four mini heart cookies, complete with a Sweetheart tag 💚💜💛💖

This sale will be available until February 6th but spots are limited so don't delay!

All pre-order sales must be paid in full at time of order, and picked up on February 13th

Ready to place your order?

Choose your favorite sugar cookies or cookie cake and let us create something special just for you!